Their story
Cornelius Moses Butler was born into slavery in Alabama. The county's register of deaths gives his birth date as January 16, 1844; other records point to the middle 1840s. He was nearly grown when freedom came, and he could not yet read or write.
By 1866 he was in Smith County, Texas. In July 1867 he registered to vote there, signing with his mark. The family and the college histories say he was taught to read, write and count by his wife, and that he went on to study at Bishop College in Marshall.
In 1876 he began preaching to the Liberty Baptist congregation in a log cabin with a puncheon floor. He served that church for nearly 48 years and baptized more than 950 people. He was one of the ministers who established the East Texas Baptist Association in 1869, and he served as its moderator for most of his life.
In 1905 he founded the East Texas Baptist Academy in Tyler, a school for Black students in East Texas, and he led it until his death. After he died, the school was renamed Butler College in his honor. It closed in 1972. A Texas Historical Marker, placed in 2008, stands near Bellwood Road in Tyler.
He married Rebecca "Puss" Warren in 1867 and Cynthia Bell Melton in the 1890s, and he was the father of more than twenty children. He died on November 19, 1924, and was buried in the Butler Cemetery at Jamestown, Smith County. More than a thousand people came to his memorial day in April 1925.
Sources: Smith County register of deaths; Texas death certificate (1924); Smith County voter registration (1867); U.S. censuses 1870–1900; The Troup Banner (1914–1925); An Era of Progress and Promise (1910); Handbook of Texas, "Butler College"; Texas Historical Commission marker 15480.